Choose A when
Melanotan I
For research on induced pigmentation without appetite/sexual side effects. Linear structure is more MC1R-selective than MT-2.
See full profileComparison
Both are melanocortin agonists, but with different selectivity and entirely different goals. MT-1 is MC1R-selective — pigmentation (FDA-approved Scenesse for EPP). PT-141 is MC4R-selective — central sexual stimulation (FDA-approved Vyleesi for HSDD in women).
| Spec | A Melanotan I | B PT-141 |
|---|---|---|
| Primary receptor | MC1R (melanocytes) | MC4R (hypothalamus) |
| Structure | Linear 13-aa analog (NDP-α-MSH) | Cyclized 7-aa analog |
| Primary effect | Melanogenesis → pigmentation (requires UV) | Sexual arousal (central) |
| FDA status | Approved (Scenesse, 2019) — EPP | Approved (Vyleesi, 2019) — HSDD in women |
| Dosing | 250-500 mcg s.c. daily (loading) | 1.0-1.75 mg s.c. as needed (max 8/month) |
| Primary side effect | Nausea, mole darkening | Nausea (40%), transient ↑BP |
Choose A when
For research on induced pigmentation without appetite/sexual side effects. Linear structure is more MC1R-selective than MT-2.
See full profileChoose B when
For central sexual arousal research — the only FDA-approved melanocortin for HSDD.
See full profileVerdict
Not alternatives — different receptors, different effects. MT-1 for pigmentation, PT-141 for sexual arousal. Both FDA-approved for specific indications.
Other comparisons